Last modified: 2022-03-19 by rob raeside
Keywords: protection | international | red cross | roerich treaty | white flag |
Links: FOTW homepage | search | disclaimer and copyright | write us | mirrors
The Red Cross (and Crescent and Star of David I assume) is recognised under international law as a symbol of protection, and has in general been recognised as such by combatants. (Yes, I'm sure we can all think of examples where it hasn't, but in general it is.)
The red cross on a white field is a symbol protected under international law, and in theory any use of it except as a symbol of medical/hospital facilities, is illegal. I think many countries have enacted this into their domestic law.
Similarly I believe the UN flag has been used to mark areas or places under
UN protection. I think it's only fair to say that its record is rather less successful.
Roy Stilling 07 March
image by Edward J. Mooney, Jr.
The white cloth is, actually, and if I understood it well, not a sign of surrender, but a sign of truce or ceasefire, and request for negotiation. However, since it is more or less that the weaker side is requesting ceasefire in any conflict, and since the result of such negotiations would in most cases result in surrender of the weaker side with more or less conditions, it is easily "extrapolated" as the surrender flag.
In times when things like war ethics were obeyed (was there ever such times?), I guess, it was usual that the "ambassador" of the other side carrying the white flag contact the other side for the "final" negotiations before the fight, to find possible ways of avoiding the battle. At least that is what we are told in many books and movies, but how much this holds, I do not know.
In any case, the white flag is nowadays often seen used by refugees and civilians
caught in the middle of battles. It is not unusual to see on TV reports a group
of civilians carrying a white flag trying to get out from between two sides. The
message sent with such white flag say something like this: "Here we are, we are
unarmed and not engaged in you conflict, we just want to get out of here. By carrying
this flag we are aware that you can shoot us easily, but we really on your mercy."
Željko Heimer, 6 March 2000
'Abroad they hold forth a white flag of accommodation and
satisfaction, and of minding the same thing which ye mind, and to be
flesh of your flesh and bone of your bone, and to invite you to their
headquarters, ...' - This is from a Leveller pamphlet which was
attacking Cromwell, Ireton and other members of the General Council of
the Army, probably written by John Wildman a soldier in the New Model
Army, in 1647 (reference source quoted: Woodhouse, Puritanism and
Liberty, p. 440).
David B. Lawrence, 16 July 2008
I had read a novel that depicted a
green flag marking a rallying point for Quakers after the Fire of
London and I sent an email to the author asking if she had an actual
source for this detail, but she did not reply. I still do not have a
source for an actual flag, but I've just read In A Free Republic
by Alison Plowden, which mentions on p. 49 the House of Commons besieged
for three days by five hundred of the 'bonny Besses in the sea-green
dresses', who were 'lusty lasses of the Levelling party' - 'green
being the colour associated with the Levellers'. 'Eventually, on 25
April, twenty ladies of the 'sea-green order' were admitted to the
Lobby with their petition' which was for the release of the Leveller
leaders taken prisoner, who later came to trial in September 1649 and
were acquitted. (Her reference source is: P. Gregg, Free-Born John: A
Biography of John Lilburne, pp. 271-2, London, Phoenix Press,2000).
David B. Lawrence, 16 July 2008