Last modified: 2008-07-19 by rob raeside
Keywords: vatican | holy see | pope | benedict xvi | catholic |
Links: FOTW homepage | search | disclaimer and copyright | write us | mirrors
Part I (this page):
Part II (next page):
Today in the first public appearance of H.H. the Pope Benedict
XVI in a balcony it was still used the Coat of Arms of H.H the Pope John Paul II. This will probably
change in the next few days, when the new Pope would have its own
Coat of Arms.
Francisco Gregoric, 19 April 2005
image by António Martins-Tuválkin, 21 October 2005
In connection with the Pope's visit to Germany, there's a
series of photos of the "Popemobile" being used for the
trip at the website of the Cologne archdiocese, including one at
showing a pennant on the left fender, white with a yellow band at
the hoist and Pope Benedict's personal arms in color in the fly.
Joe McMillan, 17 August 2005
See also photos at <www.graffitipress.it>
Zachary Harden, 19 October 2005
Here is a photo
(photographed in June 2005) of the car flag taken from <www.stthom.edu>.
Rev. William M. Becker, 23 November 2005
image by António Martins-Tuválkin, 21 May 2005
(click here for image in PNG format contributed by Colin Alberts, 28 April 2005)
Benedict XVI is the first pope of modern times who will not
use the tiara, the papal crown, in his Coat of Arms.
Jan-Patrick Fischer, 26 April 2005
Since his last three predecessors decided not to wear the
tiara, and he has decided not to wear it either, perhaps he felt
it was time to retire it from the arms also.
Ned Smith, 26 April 2005
The drawing of the arms that was included on the material
distributed at the inauguration shows a piece of headgear atop
the shield that is less ornate than the normal representation of
either the tiara or a bishop's mitre. Depending on the
artist's tastes, a mitre can be shaped just like the tiara seen
in profile (with curved sides), or it can have an angle part way
up. The headgear on the drawing is
curved. Also, three simple black bands are shown
encircling the whatever-it-is. I believe this is
simply a modernized, stylized representation of the
tiara. Others believe it is a mitre, signifying
heraldically the already established decision (since Paul VI)
renouncing the actual wearing of a tiara. Neither Benedict
XVI nor the Holy See have issued any official statement on this
matter. In fact, as of this morning, there was still
nothing official, other than the line drawing on the inauguration
programs, on the new Pope's arms.
Joe McMillan, 26 April 2005
Benedict XVI will, in fact, take new arms as pope and not use
the same shield device as he did when Cardinal. The new arms are being
devised even as I write, a sketch and explanation can be found at
(in German), a clearer image of the arms can be seen at <www.vaticanhistory.de/index.html>.
In addition to a new bearings on the shield, the ornaments will
also change. The mitre will replace the tiara and the pallium,
now the distinctive mark of the papacy, will be added.
James A. Francis, 27 April 2005
Here the personal Coat
of Arms of Pope Benedict XVI from <www.araldicavaticana.com>
[Note: this site currently show different arms
same as above]. The description (in Italian) at <www.araldicavaticana.com/descrizione_dello_stemma.htm>
[now obsolete]: "Descrizione dello stemma: Interzato
cappato: nel primo di Monaco, che è d'oro alla testa di moro
nera coronata e ornata di rosso; nel secondo di Frisinga, che è
d'oro all'orso di San Corbiniano di nero, passante, armato e
lampassato di rosso, sostenente una soma dello stesso
attraversata da una croce di Sant'Andrea d'argento; nel terzo
d'azzurro alla conchiglia d'argento."
Abbreviation: "vorl. Papstwappen" = vorlaeufiges Papstwappen = provisional Coat of Arms.
Jens Pattke, 27 April 2005
The image sent by Jens Pattke seems to show the wrong
tiara. I thought only the papal mitra is used for the personal
Dirk Schoenberger, 27 April 2005
I think that at <www.araldicavaticana.com>
it is a mitre- as Joe McMillan mentioned previously,
sometimes the outline of a mitre and a tiara can be difficult to
distinguish in a two-dimensional drawing. Perhaps in this case it
was even intentionally drawn to be a bit ambiguous. Changing from
tiara to mitre to "modernize" the arms, but keeping
enough traces to evoke a resemblance to the tiara as a slight nod
Ned Smith, 27 April 2005
The crest of this sketch, from the German site, shows a
bishop's mitre; Jens' post shows the papal tiara, which is
official (if that's the right word). On second look, it may be a
pope's mitre. I think they wear that in their capacity as bishop
of Rome. In any event, it's not the tiara, which is rarely worn.
Albert S. Kirsch, 27 April 2005
I happen to be reading "The Pope Encyclopedia: An A to Z
of the Holy See" this morning (Matthew Bunson, Crown Trade
Paperbacks, 1995), and it mentions that Paul VI stopped wearing
the tiara after Vatican II, but not that it was officially
retired by the Council. (Also that he had four tiaras to choose
from, including the one Joe described.) The critical moment seems
to have been when John Paul I chose to be invested with the
pallium instead of the tiara. John Paul II did the same at his
investiture and never subsequently wore the tiara. As Benedict
XVI's installation mass showed, that seems to be the new
A question, I suppose, is whether the tiara will ever be removed from the papal arms, and therefore from the papal flag.
Andrew S. Rogers, 27 April 2005
If is confirmed, seems evident that when assuming Pontifical
Seat the New Pope would choose re-ordering his Arms as Cardinal
that way which the cross-quartering is now manteled
in curve generating three quarters: the dexter flank in Or
(yellow) loaded with a Moor king; the sinister flank, also in Or
(yellow), presenting a bear passant in its color and disposed in
band armed with a little shield in Gules (red) with a saltire in
Argent (white); the base in Azure (blue) loads a shell in Argent
According to which is has been possible infer to us from the consulted and previously referred sources, first quarter represents Munich whereas the second one Freising: localities that conform the Archbishopric which were titular then Cardinal Ratzinger whilst the shell, symbol of conversion and baptism alludes to Saint Augustine (history of the boy who wants put the sea in a hole) and the desire of Benedict XVI to fish souls in the sea of the Humanity. Cardinal Ratzingers Motto is "Cooperatores Veritatis" ("Cooperators for the Truth"); nevertheless, even though we could consider it a fact, is preferable to wait that the Pope reafirms it before the asumption of his new responsibilities.
Finally, may be interesting to precise if the charge on the First Quarter is really a "Moor head" like it has been described in some cases because, until we can remember, such charges are usually represented like human faces in Sable (black) without another attributes and when they have it, are generally a bandage representing turbans describing it into Spanish like "cabezas de moro tortilladas (something like bandaged Moor heads"). Soon, the characteristics with usually is represented Moor heads are from black race and this particular case its an European face but enameled in black and crowned. Consequently, we bold ourselves to describe it like "Moor king" hoping that anyone of our Distinguished Colleagues has the amiability to clearing us with regards to the matter.
Raul Orta, 27 April 2005
A B&W drawing of the new Papal arms can be foun d in
today's edition of The Times newspaper, together with a
description and discussion of the history of the heraldry etc.
Ron Lahav and Ned Smith, 27 April 2005
The headdress shown in the provisional Coat of Arms is a
mitre. A tiara is usually shown with three crowns (whether
jewelled or fleuretté), and is sometimes depicted in having a
bullet-shape (smooth, round sides ending in a point), and
sometimes (as in reality) a "squished" bullet-
shape. Illustration may be seen at <www.answers.com>.
A mitre (whether bishop's, abbot's, or otherwise) may seem to be round when worn, but in reality has a stretched pentagonal shape. This is because when the bishop is not wearing it, it is folded down, so that it is not cumbersome to carry. The two "hard" edges on the sides allow it to be folded, something well nigh impossible with something like the tiara (ever tried to flatten a big piece of orange peel?). An illustration of the mitre, for comparison, can be seen at <www.murphyrobes.com>. I can vouch for this from experience, having been an altar boy, serving at masses with the the Most Rev. Anthony Tonnos, titular bishop of Naziona and Bishop of the Diocese of Hamilton, and the Most Rev. Attila Mikloshazy, S.J., titular bishop of Castel Minore and Bishop for Hungarian Emigrants throughout the world when they came to officiate at my parish (a not uncommon event, actually!). I have had the privilege to hold both their crosiers and mitres (and gotten in trouble for fiddling with the mitre!). That the mitre illustrated in the provisonal arms has three "fesses" (to use a heraldic term) may be to designate its Papal status, by incorporating the three crowns of the tiara into mitre form. This last is my personal observation, and assumption.
Georges G. Kovari, 28 April 2005
Here is an image of
Coat of Arms of HH Benedictus XVI from the German newspaper
"Sueddeutsche Zeitung"; Munich; 26 April
2005 (Info by Erich Dieter Linder).
Jens Pattke, 28 April 2005
There are very similar to the arms used when he was a
cardinal. The papal tiara has been dropped in favour of a
bishop's mitre, apparently to lessen emphasis on the regality of
the papacy, but the mitre has three gold bands echoing the three
coronets on tiara. See <heritage.villanova.edu>.
Garry Dent, 29 April 2005
there is a new version for the Coat of Arms would be use by
Benedict XVI. Here is part of the text that accompanies it,
written up by Monsignor Guy Silvester:
"The Pope was Installed last Sunday. We still await official word on the Coat of Arms of Benedict XVI. Archbishop Andrea Cordero Lanza di Montezemolo (...) designed the new pope's arms and added two innovations: the pallium and a mitre instead of the tiara. The pallium is ill-placed and Catholic bishops do not ensign their arms with a mitre as per legislation laid down in 1969 by Pope Paul VI. So, these innovations are weird and unofficial. The tiara is still the symbol in heraldry for the arms of a pope. A mitre with two keys would indicate the arms of an Anglican Bishop! I personally believe there is this lag in the Holy See displaying the arms of the pope because they are still tweaking it so that it looks less bizarre. Nevertheless, it seems the design of the shield has been settled on. It is illustrated at right".
However, judging by the image in this opportunity it's possible to appreciate that the contour of the field still has not been defined; on second quarter, was enameled in Sable (black) the vane with which is joined the bulk or knapsack to the bear and on the third one was replaced enamels entirely: Azure (blue) by Gules (red) on the field and Argent (white) by Or (yellow) for the shell. As far as ornaments, in this opportunity appears a tiara like crest.
Raul Orta, 29 April 2005
The tinctures of his arms are exactly those of the German arms
and flag: red, black and golden yellow.
Juan Jose Morales, 30 April 2005
Guy Silvester wrote in his site <www.home.earthlink.net/~herald97/guyselvester>:
THE NEW POPE AND TRADITION
During the past week I have received a huge number of emails asking me what I think about the fact that the Pope has "broken with tradition" by not using the Papal Tiara (or triregno) on his coat of arms. I reply that as far as I know he has done no such thing.
The drawing of the papal arms that was used on the card or programme from his Installation was obviously thrown together in just a few days. It may not yet be the final version. In addition, the article which appeared in l'Osservatore Romano doesn't impress me as definitive either. That newspaper is the UNofficial paper of the Vatican and the article was simply an interview with Archbishop Montezemolo (who drew the arms). He's a retired Vatican diplomat who is an amateur heraldist.
So much has been made of the fact that, as Catholic News Service put it, the "tiara has once again been given the boot". We don't know that has happened. The Sala Stampa (the OFFICIAL source of news about the Holy See and the Pope) has said nothing on the matter yet and the image of the Pope's arms has yet to appear anywhere on the Vatican website. In fact, on the Pope's bio page they're still displaying the arms he bore as cardinal. All this suggests to me that there may very well still be more work being done. When John XXIII was Pope he sent (the late) poor Bruno Heim back to the drawing board three times just to get the facial features of the lion in his coat of arms correct!
It is, I think, important to note the following. In my personal opinion the impetus to remove the tiara from the papal arms has not come from the Pope. Rather, it is those around him who are thinking liturgically but know very little heraldically who are urging this to happen. They make much out of the fact that the tiara is no longer worn. Big deal! It remains as a heraldic symbol whether it is worn or not! The galeros (ecclesiastical hats) that ensign the arms of all clerics (see my heraldry page) aren't worn anymore either but they remain as a heraldic symbol. The two keys of Peter used in Papal arms don't even exist! They are just a symbol of the power to bind and to loose. This Pope is very interested in maintaining a connection to the tradition of the Church (evidenced by his decision to deliver his first message to the Church in Latin and to use that Universal language of the Church for his Inastallation Mass as well) so I think there may be a chance yet that the tiara is maintained in his arms. Catholic bishops do not ensign their shields with a mitre. In fact, they have been forbidden to do so in legislation laid down by Pope Paul VI in 1969!
It is also important to note that even if the mitre/tiara hybrid created by Montezemolo is maintained in the papal arms that does not mean that the Pope will be changing heraldic custom. Instead he'll simply be ignoring it in the same way that including the pallium in a Papal coat of arms ignores heraldic custom. The external ornaments that indicate the rank of the bearer of a particular coat of arms are often in dispute...especially in the Church. To this day many prelates want to use ornaments to which they aren't entitled or eschew the ornaments they should use.
What really matters is what is on the shield. That, after all, is the actual coat of arms. Pope Benedict XVI has chosen arms which may not be to everyone's liking but which are heraldically sound. As to the ornaments surrounding the shield, well, artistic license is permitted and surely will be used. His arms will continue to be depicted ensigned by the Papal tiara whether he likes it or not! The bottom line remains that the triregno is the symbol of the papacy and will remain such no matter what hybrid, bizarre form some heraldic dabblers choose to put it in.
When there is an official announcement then we'll all know for sure (...)
Raul Orta, 30 April 2005
The apparently final version has no blue or white; the bottom
field was changed to a yellow shell on red.
But I think the color combination has nothing to do with German patriotism; it happens to be the color combination in the arms of the diocese of Munich and Freising and the city of Freising, which occupy the upper two fields of the pope's arms. Both long predating the Schwarz-Rot-Gold of the German flag.
Joe McMillan, 1 May 2005
See image and explanation in Spanish at <www.corazones.org>.
Nelson L. Roman, 2 May 2005
"The coat of arms of Pope Benedict XVI incorporates both papal elements, as well as the elements of the coat of arms he bore as Archbishop of München (Munich) and Freising, and as the Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.
Miter. The miter replaces the "beehive" tiara familiar from former papal coats of arms. Pope Paul VI dropped the ceremonial use of the tiara, although he, and his immediate successors John Paul I and John Paul II, retained it in their coats of arms. Benedict XVI has replaced it with the miter, on which is emblazoned three gold bands representing "order, jurisdiction and magisterium."
These are the symbolic equivalents of the three layers of the tiara. They are connected into a unity by the vertical gold strip, representing the unity of these three kinds of authority in the person of the Supreme Pontiff.
Pallium. The use of the white pallium with black crosses draped below the shield is a new addition to papal coats of arms. It represents episcopal authority, the special kind of jurisdiction that is reserved to metropolitan archbishops in their province and to the pope universally in the Church, what is called the plenitudo pontificalis officii (i.e. the plenitude of pontifical office). The style of pallium shown on the coat of arms, black crosses on a narrow band of wool, is what is commonly known from the second millennium, though the crosses have sometimes been red, sometimes black. At his inaugural Mass, Pope Benedict wore an older style of pallium, broad with red crosses, and hanging down from the left shoulder rather than in the middle. This style is more typical of the first millennium, and similar to the omophorion representing episcopal authority in the Eastern Church.
Crossed Keys. The two crossed keys symbolize the powers Christ gave to the Apostle Peter and to his successors.
"I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven." (Matthew 16:19)
The gold key represents the power to bind in heaven and the silver key spiritual authority on earth. The two keys are united by the cord, again indicating their essential unity in Peter and his successors.
Caput Ethiopicum. According to the website of his former Archdiocese:
"The shield, which is divided into three sections, displays the Moor of Freising." The Moors head, facing left and typically crowned, appeared on the coat of arms of the old principality of Freising as early as 1316, during the reign of the Bishop of Freising, Prince Konrad III, and it remained almost unchanged until the secularization of the Churchs estates in that region in 1802-1803. Ever since that time the archbishops of Munich and Freising have included the Caput Aethiopum, the head of an Ethiopian, in their episcopal coat of arms."
Bear of Corbinian. Also present on the coat of arms is a bear with a pack-saddle, the so-called Bear of Corbinian." The saintly Bishop Corbinian preached the Christian faith in the Duchy of Bavaria in the 8th century and is considered the spiritual father and patron of the archdiocese. A legend states that he traveled to Rome with a bear as his pack-animal, after having commanded it to do so. Once he arrived, he released the bear from his service, and it returned to Bavaria. The implication is that "Christianity tamed and domesticated the ferocity of paganism and thus laid the foundations for a great civilization in the Duchy of Bavaria." At the same time, Corbinians Bear, as Gods beast of burden, symbolizes the burden of office.
Scallop Shell. The symbolism of the shell is multiple. St. Augustine, Bishop and Doctor of the Church (354-430 AD), was once walking along the seashore, meditating on the unfathomable mystery of the Holy Trinity. A boy was using a shell to pour seawater into a little hole. When Augustine asked him what he was doing, he replied, I am emptying the sea into this hole. Thus did Augustine understand that man would never penetrate to the depths of the mystery of God. Fr. Joseph Ratzinger, in 1953, wrote his doctoral dissertation on The People of God and the House of God in Augustines Teaching about the Church," and therefore has a personal connection with the thought of this great Doctor of the Church.
The shell also stands for pilgrimage, for Jacobs staff, a pilgrims staff topped with a scallop shell. In Church art it is a symbol of the apostle James the Great, and his sanctuary at Santiago de Compostela in Spain, perhaps the principal place of pilgrimage during the middle ages. This symbol alludes, as well, to the pilgrim people of God, a title for the Church which Joseph Ratzinger championed at the Second Vatican Council as peritus (theological adviser) to Cardinals Frings of Köln (Cologne). When he became Archbishop he took the shell in his coat of arms. It is also found in the insignia of the Schottenkloster in Regensburg, where the major seminary of that diocese is located, a place where Benedict XVI taught as a professor of theology.
We do not yet know what the motto of Pope Benedict XVI will be. However, his episcopal motto was "cooperatores veritatis" (collaborators of the truth)."
William Belanich, 2 May 2005
Agreed the pallium is new, but disagree on the tiara. What is
shown as a mitre still bears the three gold circlets which were
the feature of the tiara and refer to the three realms of papal
authority. In effect this is a simplification of the
tiara, not a substitution.
Michael Faul, 5 May 2005
The tiara, as also the mitre, hat, chapeau, and any such
headgear, is equivalent to the helm of a knightly coat of arms.
A full achievement including a tiara could include a crest
- as well as a crown, wreath, mantle, motto scroll, war-cry,
supporters/tenants, compartment, collar(s), or trophies, but not
António Martins-Tuválkin, 18 May 2005
According to the image now at Vatican.VA,
the bear is brown and its cargo is red with a black saltire; the
three crosses on the pallium are red.
António Martins-Tuválkin, 21 May 2005
The pallium is worn by metropolitan archbishops within their
own area of jurisdiction only, but worn by The Holy Father
everywhere. Benedict XVI was invested with this at his
Inauguration Ceremony. One of the better online descriptions is
to be found here on The Vatican's
own web site, in the remarks of John Paul the Great at his
General Audience of Wednesday 30 June 1999: " The pallium is
a small circular band in the form of a stole, set with six
crosses. It is woven of white wool from the shearing of lambs
blessed every year on 21 January, the feast of St Agnes. The Pope
confers the pallium on newly appointed Metropolitan Archbishops.
It expresses the authority which, in communion with the Church of
Rome, the Metropolitan acquires by law in his own Ecclesiastical
Province (General Audience of John Paul II Wednesday 30 June
1999, CIC, can. 437, §1)."
On this page you can see a picture of The Holy Father wearing his pallium on the outside of his papal vestments. The gold coloured nails symbolise those used to nail Jesus to the cross.
Colin Dobson, 21 May 2005
According to Catholic
News Service: "The details of the new papal blazon were
first published in the April 28 edition of the Vatican newspaper,
L'Osservatore Romano. A copy was released April 27 to
Kristian Söderberg, 26 May 2005
For continuation see Part II